Island Song Opening (feat. Jeremy Jordan, Kimiko Glenn, Jackie Burns, Lilli Cooper & Troy Iwata)
Looking for a Little Room (feat. Lilli Cooper)
Wall Lovin' (feat. Jeremy Jordan)
I'll Take It All (feat. Jackie Burns)
T.M.I. (feat. Kimiko Glenn)
No Room for Plan B (feat. Troy Iwata)
Transition: Too Much (feat. Lilli Cooper & Jackie Burns)
Hipster Youth I (feat. Jeremy Jordan, Kimiko Glenn & Troy Iwata)
So Far from Pennsylvania (feat. Lilli Cooper)
So Many Windows (feat. Jeremy Jordan, Kimiko Glenn, Jackie Burns, Lilli Cooper & Troy Iwata)
Tie Me Up (feat. Jeremy Jordan & Jackie Burns)
Dancing in Pairs (feat. Kimiko Glenn)
Moments After Midnight
So Many Windows Reprise (feat. Lilli Cooper)
Stay Awhile (feat. Jeremy Jordan)
Island Song Reprise (feat. Jeremy Jordan, Kimiko Glenn, Jackie Burns, Lilli Cooper & Troy Iwata)
Hipster Youth II (feat. Jeremy Jordan, Kimiko Glenn & Troy Iwata)
Wall Lovin' / Stay Awhile Reprise (feat. Jeremy Jordan)
Sing, But Don't Tell (feat. Kimiko Glenn)
One More at Deluxe (feat. Jeremy Jordan & Jackie Burns)
After Hours (feat. Lilli Cooper)
New York, Do You Care? (feat. Jackie Burns)
Make It Here (feat. Troy Iwata)
Too Much (feat. Jeremy Jordan, Kimiko Glenn, Jackie Burns, Lilli Cooper & Troy Iwata)
Bonus Track: Waiting (From Expanded Version) [feat. Natalie Weiss]
Bonus Track: Toothbrush (From High School Edition) [feat. Hanna Berggren & Stanley Graham]
